Howdy folks,

There’s a new sheriff in town on the wild west of the internet, and it’s not playing by the rules. AI companies are throwing caution to the wind and ignoring long-standing internet protocols. This could reshape the digital landscape as we know it.

The Rise of Rogue AI Bots

Remember dial-up internet? (I can still hear that screeching modem sound in my nightmares.) Back then, web developers created a simple solution to prevent automated bots from overwhelming websites: the robots.txt file. This hidden text file acts as a digital “No Trespassing” sign, telling well-behaved bots which parts of a website they can and can’t access.

For nearly 30 years, this system worked like a charm. Tech giants like Google and Facebook played nice, respecting these virtual boundaries. But now, AI companies are crashing the party, and they’re not interested in following the house rules.

AI’s Insatiable Appetite for Data

Why the sudden change? It all comes down to data – the lifeblood of artificial intelligence. AI models are hungry beasts, and they need massive amounts of information to learn and grow. Web scraping, which is the practice of automatically collecting data from websites, has become their favorite feeding ground.

Colleen Chien, a professor at UC Berkeley Law School, explains the importance of the robots.txt file: “It puts a sign in front of that website to say, if you’re a robot, you need to abide by the rules here. This is where you aren’t welcome.”

But AI companies are increasingly treating these signs as mere suggestions rather than hard-and-fast rules. Take Perplexity, a popular AI search engine, for example. When questioned about their practices, they bluntly stated, “robots.txt is not a legal framework.” Ouch.

The Ripple Effect

Now, you might be thinking, “So what? Who cares about some techie mumbo-jumbo?” Well because this seemingly small act of defiance could have big consequences for how we all use the internet.

Jacob Hoffman-Andrews, a former Google engineer, paints a stark picture of what could happen if this trend continues: “There’s a chance for that whole kind of open-web-based order to break down. The websites that do exist could retreat behind logins and become private communities. The concept of the internet as the world’s biggest library would start to fail.”

Imagine a world where every website requires a login, where paywalls become the norm, and where the free flow of information grinds to a halt. It’s not just about inconvenience – it’s about the very nature of the internet as we know it.

David vs. Goliath: The Battle for Data Control

At its core, this issue boils down to a classic struggle between big tech and, well, everyone else. AI companies are getting rich off the data they scrape, while content creators and website owners are left empty-handed.

Chien puts it bluntly: “As these models become more and more powerful, the question of who gets to keep the riches that are generated by these amazing new technologies is increasingly important.”

It’s no wonder that ignoring robots.txt has become a rallying cry against the AI industry in Silicon Valley. Website owners are fighting back, but they’re outgunned and outmanned.

Open Web or Walled Gardens?

As AI companies continue to push the boundaries of what’s acceptable online, we’re left with a crucial question: What kind of internet do we want?

On one side, we have the promise of incredibly powerful AI tools that could revolutionize how we search for and interact with information. On the other, we face the potential loss of the open, accessible web that has defined the internet for decades.

The robots.txt file may seem like a small, technical detail, but it represents a much larger battle for the soul of the internet. As AI reshapes our digital world, we’ll need to grapple with tough questions about ethics, fairness, and the balance between innovation and respect for established norms.

Sources:

Artificial intelligence web crawlers are running amok, Bobby Allyn:

https://www.npr.org/2024/07/05/nx-s1-5026932/artificial-intelligence-web-crawlers-are-running-amok

---

Frank Bixler, founder of the AI Daily Digest and Web Copy Services, demystifies AI and automation for businesses. With a knack for translating tech-speak, he’s on a mission to make workflow optimization accessible. Whether crafting insights or streamlining processes, Frank’s all about tech that works for you.

Reach out to him at frankbix.wcs@gmail.com or https://www.linkedin.com/in/frankbixler/